I’ve got mixed feelings about this book. It’s an undoubted classic of its time of that there is no doubt, and if I was reviewing it back in its first publication date of 1964, or even when it was fully revised in 1992, I would be very enthusiastic about it. But today, I’m less than enthusiastic, mainly because it is a strange mixture of ancient and modern that, for me, doesn’t work. The bulk of the book is in its original form, complete with the tackle, baits and methods of the day, and then we have the updated portions that appear to be bolted on. If you like nostalgia and wish to read about how fishing used to be 50 years ago then you could very well enjoy the book, but I would think such a reader would far more enjoy finding an earlier edition in a second hand bookshop. If you’re a cool, modern angler then this book isn’t for you at all. A small, but nevertheless annoying point is that the publicity sheet that came with the book continually refers to Colin Willock as Colin Willcock. How can you enthuse about a man whose name you can’t even get right? A man of Colin Willock’s stature deserves better than that. Rating: 7/10 |