Does Bob Nudd have a brain at all?

[Adrian Bartle]

Why cull cormorants? or for that matter boring old anglers and immigrants? that goes against what earlier posters are saying "it's nature, don't mess it" are Cormorants or people not part of nature?..............

 

[Adrian Bartle]

Should've been "don't mess with it"

 

[Adrian Bartle]

And above all of this, we know that the 'The News of the World' always reports accurate and exactly quoted comment don't we?

 

[Les Clark]

Harvey i think that you are missing the point somewhat,you don`t care what you catch you say ,so does that mean in your veiw , sod the imbalance on a lot of waters or put another way ,i`m all right jack has long as i`m catching ?
As for your last sentence ,i could`nt make out if you where telling Bob Nudd to stop whinging or the people on this thread to stop whinging about Bob Nudd ?
If it is the latter then why bother posting just go back to sticking your head in the sand .

 

[Harvey Thorkildsen]

its nature there cant be that much of an imbalance can there if there aint any food then they wont live im talking about bob whinging pike are there for a reason tough as that is nature

 

[Steve Grantham]

has anyone told bob there are to many people killing pike and taking them home to eat ! and he wants a bloody cull!

 

[Dave Morris]

You would think a man of Bobs stature in the fishing world have the knowledge to realise how important pike are to the balance of any waters.I personally would not want to slag of Bob personally as he is a vastly experienced angler but he should really know better.Remember fish seemed to survive together for years before man interfered.Another point "Anglers Should be Sticking Together In These Potentially Troubled Times"

 

[Steve Husband]

pike left to themselves usually sort themselves out .Jack pike are the favourite food for the bigger pike

 

[Lee Swords]

I see no Bob article in todays NOTW....

 

[captain carrott]

yas i had a carp earlier this year on a spinner think i was trying to catch one of them perch things at the time.

 

[Gary Knowles]

apparently cull doesn't mean kill....

 

[Lee Swords]

Is thet the official line?

Not seen the papers yet

 

[Adrian Bartle]

It does, but it also means to select or pick out

 

[Lee Swords]

What do you do with the selected then?


send them to finishing school in Switzerland?

 

[Les Clark]

No Swordsy , restaurants in france, thats what happened to culled pike from a big res down here many years ago ,we were told they were going into other club waters , instead someone was putting ? notes into his wallet .

 

[Lee Swords]

Quennelles du Brochet no doubt!

 

[David Marrs]

Bob Nudd has been spouting rubbish regarding predators in the press for many a long year now. Very strange though, that many of his Fenland winter haunts, full of 'silverfish', are also absolutely prime predator waters!

The guy is extremely ignorant in my view and I don't take him seriously, especially when he fronts a column in a proper comic. To me, blokes like Bob don't even take enough pleasure in the individual fish they catch to bother with them, its just 'silverfish' or 'pasties'! Nah, the guy is a dork.

 

[Lee Swords]

Read his bit in the paper today!


He still doesn't get it does he?


Jeez the man has got tunnel vision!

 

[captain carrott]

my original question answered i thnk.

 

[captain carrott]

and in response to those who said it wouldn't start some morons off killing pike.

it would appear that i was the one who was correct when i said his moronic comments would start them killing pike as it appears it has already started.

so possibly you could now retract you nudd appologist remarks and concede that fact that his words were stupid.

any failure to do so will put you as people firmly in the kill alll pike camp.