Just in case I may have inadvertently offended!
My choice of wording in my previous post may have been poor, so just to be clear, when I said “ seems wrong to reach for a (barbed) hook” I did not mean to imply that it is wrong to use barbed hooks. I have just got so used to using barbless, using a barbed hook would feel strange for me. I still carry loads of barbed hooks and would use them if I felt the situation required them.
I started using barbless when grayling fishing since I found them difficult to unhook.